Justice Delayed: Boeing Escapes Criminal Charges After 737 Max Tragedies

Boeing has narrowly escaped criminal charges in connection to the devastating 737 Max crashes that claimed the lives of 346 individuals in 2018 and 2019. A ruling from Judge Reed O’Connor granted the US government’s request to dismiss the case despite expressing disagreement over whether it aligns with public interest. This decision represents a significant legal victory for Boeing, which previously entered a guilty plea following accusations of fraudulent behavior regarding flight control software concealment.

Families of the victims fiercely opposed the dismissal, arguing for accountability within the judicial system. Attorney Paul Cassell, representing some of the families, plans to appeal the ruling, asserting that the courts must not remain passive while injustices occur.

Despite doubts raised by Judge O’Connor concerning the government’s stance, he acknowledged the Department of Justice’s good faith in negotiating a new deal with Boeing. The DOJ contends that the agreement offers finality for victims while mandating Boeing to undertake substantial safety commitments.

The saga traces back to Boeing’s prior criminal fraud conspiracy charge, which arose after revelations that it concealed critical information from regulators. Although the company admitted wrongdoing and previously paid billions in fines, the deal was reopened following a separate incident involving a dislodged door from a 737 Max during flight.

Under a new settlement, the criminal charge was dropped, signifying a potential relaxation of Boeing’s government contractor status concerns, while requiring them to employ an independent compliance consultant and fulfill additional financial obligations. Prosecutors justified their decision to drop charges by stating that Boeing has made considerable progress in improving its safety and compliance programs this year.